Construction Compliance · New York City

Alt-1 vs Alt-2 vs Alt-3 permits in NYC

By Policyhold Team, Compliance operationsPublished Updated 7 min readSources & references
  • Alt 2 permit NYC
  • ALT1
  • ALT3
  • DOB NOW
  • general contractors
Share

Policyhold Team, Compliance operations. Practical guidance for GC compliance and mobilization operations.

New York City alteration permits are still described as Alt-1, Alt-2, and Alt-3. The Department of Buildings acquire-permits page defines ALT1 as a major alteration that will change use, egress, or occupancy, ALT2 as multiple types of work that do not, and ALT3 as one type of minor work that does not. In DOB NOW: Build, former Alt-1 work is an Alteration CO filing, and former Alt-2 and Alt-3 work are Alteration filings. General contractors should match the scope to that definition before anyone promises a letter of completion or a new certificate of occupancy.

What is an Alt-1 permit?

Alt-1 (ALT1): A major alteration that will change the building's use, egress, or occupancy, as the Department describes it on the acquire-permits page.

That is the filing people mean when the work changes how the building is used, how people exit, or how many people it is occupied by. A new or amended certificate of occupancy is the closeout people associate with this scope. DOB's own job-type guide says to confirm that by the questions in DOB NOW, not by the words "Alt-1" in a proposal.

In DOB NOW: Build, this job is Alteration CO (ALT-CO), formerly Alt-1. The Department's job-type materials say the system asks a series of questions. If any answer is yes, the job is ALT-CO and will result in a certificate of occupancy rather than only a letter of completion. The questions listed in that guide are:

  1. Is the alteration required to meet New Building requirements?
  2. Is the alteration inconsistent with the current certificate of occupancy?
  3. Is there an alteration in occupancy or use?
  4. Is there a major change to exits?
  5. Is there an alteration in the number of stories?

A yes on the first question can produce the related job type New Building with Existing Elements to Remain. Do not force that scope into an ordinary alteration because the contract still says "renovation."

ALT-CO also pulls in general construction as a work type because a schedule of occupancy is required. Other work types may be added. The applicant of record, not the GC's superintendent, answers the occupancy questions. The GC's job is to notice when field scope has drifted into one of those five yes answers and to stop work that the current filing does not cover.

What is an Alt-2 permit?

Alt-2 (ALT2): Multiple types of work that do not affect use, egress, or occupancy.

This is the common commercial and residential alteration: more than one trade, without a change to use, egress, or occupancy. Examples of "multiple types" are combinations such as general construction plus mechanical, plumbing, or sprinkler work. The acquire-permits page does not publish a dollar threshold that separates Alt-2 from Alt-3. The split it publishes is the number of work types, and whether use, egress, or occupancy changes.

In DOB NOW, former Alt-2 filings are Alteration jobs, not ALT-CO jobs, as long as every certificate-of-occupancy question is answered no. The Department's job-type comparison maps Alteration Type 2 to Alteration. People still say "Alt-2" on site. The record you can track is the Alteration job number in DOB NOW.

Closeout for work that does not affect the certificate of occupancy is the letter of completion path described in the job-type materials. Say "letter of completion" only after you have seen that the filing is an Alteration and not an ALT-CO. A scope change that adds a new occupancy, a story, or a major exit change can move the job out of Alt-2. That is a filing change, not a field extra.

What is an Alt-3 permit?

Alt-3 (ALT3): One type of minor work that does not affect use, egress, or occupancy.

The acquire-permits definition turns on a single minor work type and on leaving use, egress, and occupancy alone. DOB NOW maps Alteration Type 3 to the same Alteration job type it uses for former Alt-2 work. The old Alt-2 versus Alt-3 label is still how many contracts and expeditors talk. Inside DOB NOW, both sit under Alteration unless the scope triggers ALT-CO.

Because the system no longer keeps Alt-2 and Alt-3 as separate job types, do not argue from the nickname. Open the filing and read the job type and the work types. One work type that later grows a second work type, or that starts to affect egress, is no longer the minor filing you started with.

The acquire-permits page says that most often a New York State licensed professional engineer or registered architect must file plans before work begins. It also says some minor work does not require a permit at all, and that a professional or the borough office can explain those exceptions. Do not treat "Alt-3" as a synonym for "no permit." If the work needs a permit, it needs the filing. If someone believes it is exempt, get that determination from the professional or the borough office before the trade starts.

How do the three filings compare?

Filing people still sayDOB acquire-permits definitionDOB NOW job typeCloseout the job-type guide associates with it
Alt-1Major alteration that will change use, egress, or occupancyAlteration CO (ALT-CO), formerly Alt-1Certificate of occupancy
Alt-2Multiple types of work, not affecting use, egress, or occupancyAlterationLetter of completion, when the job does not affect the certificate of occupancy
Alt-3One type of minor work, not affecting use, egress, or occupancyAlterationLetter of completion, when the job does not affect the certificate of occupancy

Alteration CO: The DOB NOW job type for work that changes the certificate of occupancy, including former Alt-1 filings.

Letter of completion: The completion document DOB associates with alteration work that does not change the certificate of occupancy.

The acquire-permits page tells every project, regardless of type, to determine the permits, file drawings, obtain plan approval, pull the permit, do the approved work, pass final inspections, and then receive either a new or amended certificate of occupancy or a letter of completion. Which of those two endings you get is a consequence of the job type, not of how fast the trades finish.

What still stalls an Alt-1, Alt-2, or Alt-3?

The alteration type does not waive the permit record. The same operational failures stop issuance on all three:

  • The contractor insurance or license record is not accepted.
  • The designated contractor has not completed the permit request.
  • A required item, attestation, or plan-exam objection is still open.
  • The scope in the field no longer matches the approved filing.

Use the DOB NOW guide for the path from an approved filing through the permit request, renewal, inspection, and closeout. Use the permit-delay guide when you need the failed status and the person who can resubmit it. Insurance defects belong on the NYC DOB insurance requirements checklist. None of those problems are unique to Alt-2, which is why an "Alt-2 should be simple" schedule still slips.

When the scope changes after approval, the applicant files the amendment DOB requires. A post-approval amendment that answers one of the ALT-CO questions yes is a different job type, not a cleaner version of the original Alt-2. Stop the extra scope until the filing covers it. Working outside the permit is a separate enforcement problem from a slow review.

Keep one log for the job number, the DOB NOW job type, the work types, the insurance expiration, and the document you expect at the end: certificate of occupancy or letter of completion. That log is what lets a project engineer answer "is this an Alt-2?" with the record, instead of with the estimate.

Sources

Reference starting points for GC compliance teams. Verify requirements with counsel and your owner contract.

  • NYC DOB: Acquire permits

    Defines ALT1, ALT2, and ALT3 and the path from filing through a certificate of occupancy or letter of completion.

  • NYC DOB: Job types in DOB NOW

    Maps Alt-1 to Alteration CO and Alt-2 and Alt-3 to Alteration, and lists the questions that force an ALT-CO filing.

Frequently asked questions

Quick answers to common questions from GC compliance teams.

On the Department of Buildings acquire-permits page, ALT2 is multiple types of work that do not affect use, egress, or occupancy. In DOB NOW: Build, former Alt-2 work is filed as an Alteration, which the Department distinguishes from an Alteration CO filing.

Related resources