Builder's risk vs general liability for construction projects
By Policyhold Team, Compliance operations·Published ·Updated ·6 min read·Sources & references
builder's risk insurance
general liability
course of construction
subcontractor certificates
Share
Policyhold Team, Compliance operations. Practical guidance for GC compliance and mobilization operations.
Builder's risk and general liability answer different losses on the same job. Builder's risk is property insurance for the project during construction. Commercial general liability is liability insurance for bodily injury and property damage the insured causes to others. A builder's risk policy on the project does not clear a subcontractor to mobilize, and a subcontractor's general liability certificate does not insure the building as course-of-construction property. General contractors should file both records when the contract calls for both, and they should read the contract for who buys the property policy.
What is builder's risk insurance?
Builder's risk: Property insurance designed to cover property in the course of construction. IRMI's glossary describes it that way and notes that there is no single standard form. Most policies are written on inland marine forms rather than on a standard commercial-property form. Coverage is usually written on an all-risks basis and often applies at the site, at off-site storage, and in transit. The limit is commonly the estimated completed value, whether the policy is written on a completed-value basis or a reporting basis.
People also call it course-of-construction insurance. Many forms stay in force during construction and end when the work is complete and the project is occupied or put to its intended use. The form in your file states the end date. A GC should not invent one.
What the policy can include varies. Materials and the structure under construction are the core. Some forms add temporary structures, stored materials, or soft costs by endorsement. Some exclude faulty workmanship except for ensuing loss. Those are policy terms, not features you can assume because a broker said "builder's risk is in place."
The certificate or evidence of property insurance for this policy is not an ACORD 25 general-liability certificate. If the only PDF in the folder is a subcontractor's liability certificate, you do not have the builder's risk record yet.
What is commercial general liability?
Commercial general liability (CGL): A standard liability policy that protects a business against claims for bodily injury and property damage arising out of premises, operations, products, and completed operations, and against personal and advertising injury. IRMI describes the ISO commercial general liability policy, introduced in 1986, in those terms. It replaced the older "comprehensive" general liability name. People still say GL. On a construction certificate, this is the general liability row.
CGL is third-party insurance. It responds when the insured is alleged to have caused injury or damage to someone else, subject to the insuring agreement, the exclusions, and the limits. It is not a promise to replace the insured's own work, and it is not a property policy on the project. Construction claims often test those boundaries. Whether a particular crack, delay, or defect is covered is a question for the policy and, when there is a claim, for the carrier and counsel. It is not a question the certificate checkbox can settle.
Subcontractors carry their own CGL. The GC carries its own. An owner may require both. A wrap-up or owner-controlled program can change who buys the liability policy for on-site work. Even then, read what the wrap replaces and which policies the subcontract still requires. This article does not describe a specific wrap-up form.
How do the two policies differ?
Question
Builder's risk
Commercial general liability
What kind of insurance is it?
First-party property insurance for the work under construction
Third-party liability insurance
What is it purchased to cover?
Loss to the project property during construction, as the form defines it
Covered bodily injury and property damage to others arising from operations, premises, products, and completed operations
What is the limit usually based on?
The estimated completed value of the project
The per-occurrence and aggregate limits on the liability policy
Who is protected?
The named insureds and others the property form includes
The insured, against claims by other parties
What it does not replace
The subcontractor's liability, auto, and workers compensation policies
A property policy on the work in place
What the GC files
The property evidence the contract names, for this project
Each party's liability certificate and the required endorsements
First-party insurance: Coverage for the insured's own covered property. Third-party insurance: Coverage for the insured's legal obligation to pay others for covered injury or damage.
Both policies can be discussed after the same fire or collapse. That does not make them interchangeable. The property policy is where the project looks for the cost of the damaged work, subject to its exclusions. The liability policy is where an injured person, or the owner of other damaged property, looks for a covered claim against an insured. Which policy responds, and in what order, depends on the forms. Do not decide that in the submittal log.
Who usually buys builder's risk?
The construction contract assigns the purchase. On many commercial jobs the owner buys it, or the general contractor buys it and charges it to the job. Some contracts require the GC to buy it and to name the owner and the subcontractors as insureds to the extent the form allows. Some owner programs buy it inside a larger controlled-insurance program.
Read the general conditions before you tell a subcontractor that "the GC's policy covers the work." Then collect the evidence the contract describes: the carrier, the project location, the limit, the term, and the named insureds. If the contract is silent, the project team should get a written assignment from the person authorized to place the policy. Trade custom is not a certificate.
The party that buys builder's risk still does not, by that purchase, satisfy the subcontract's insurance exhibit. The exhibit is aimed at the subcontractor's own liability and statutory policies.
Which subcontractor certificates does a GC still collect?
Collect the liability certificate and the endorsements the exhibit lists. For a typical commercial subcontract that still means general liability, workers compensation, and automobile liability when vehicles are in the work, plus additional insured and waiver terms when the contract requires them. The subcontractor insurance requirements guide is the verification list. What a certificate of insurance is explains why that certificate is a summary and not the policy.
Keep the two files apart:
Project property file. Builder's risk or other course-of-construction evidence, the limit, the term, and the parties the contract requires to be named.
Vendor liability file. One certificate per subcontractor, the matching endorsements, and the expiration dates you will monitor.
A subcontractor asking to "be added to the builder's risk" is asking for a property-policy question. A subcontractor sending only that email has not delivered a general liability certificate. Answer the property question from the contract. Continue the liability review on its own track.
When the builder's risk term ends at substantial completion or occupancy, the liability policies do not end with it. Completed-operations exposure on the general liability policy is one reason the liability file stays open after the property policy expires. Renewal dates on subcontractor certificates still need an owner after the builder's risk binder is closed.
No limit in this article is a recommended minimum. The property limit follows the completed value and the form. The liability limits follow the exhibit. If either number is missing, the file is incomplete. Do not fill the gap with a figure from another job.
Sources
Reference starting points for GC compliance teams. Verify requirements with counsel and your owner contract.
National Association of Insurance Commissioners reference materials for property and liability insurance.
Frequently asked questions
Quick answers to common questions from GC compliance teams.
Builder's risk is property insurance for the work under construction. Commercial general liability is insurance for claims that the insured caused bodily injury or property damage to others. One policy does not take the place of the other.